by jgflawn » Sat Mar 08, 2014 11:23 am
In the middle of vacuuming, I thought of a good way to illustrate.
Lets assume the same B&S engine with an operating range of 1200 to 4000 rpm is used on three different snowblowers
1. 24" dual stage, with friction wheel - 5 speeds
2. 30" dual stage, with friction wheel - 5 speeds
3. 30" dual stage, with hydrostatic transmission, infinite user control of ground speed.
The factory set rpm for these 3 machines should be different - resulting in different recommended maximum BHP for each for efficient governor control. Lower potential load in 24" than 30" because of width, so higher rpm allowed on the 24" for any given ground speed. However, on the hydrostatic, given the user has infinite control of ground speed, and can control the load on the machine, slowing it down to a snail pace if necessary, allowing the governor a closer tolerance to maximum BHP. However, user education required to slow the machine, otherwise the machine will bog down, start puffing black smoke as the throttle opens full, until it finally stalls under load. You only need to think what would happen if you went on forward speed 5 into 30" of end of drive... If I purchase a B&S engine to bolt onto one of these machines, do I just go with the factory set rpm even though end use isn't know when it is set? nope. That engine can be used on a rototiller, log splitter, chipper, snowblower. Lets face it, that's where small engine shops are the expert and use a tach to set rpm. sometimes only 100 or 200 rpm here or there.. but that makes a difference.
The following from Honda:
"The engine speed setting must be chosen so that even if maximum load is suddenly applied, the engine speed may not drop below the point where maximum torque is developed; this speed setting assures good performance and fuel economy."
But if the user has control of maximum load via ground speed....
Given load for a snowblower is determined by snow condition (fluffy versus wet), width of machine, depth of snow, AND ground speed, there is considerable room for adjustment. To just set at 3600 rpm and be done with it, when 3800 rpm (which is within engine specs) will throw the snow 10' further, and at a faster ground speed under less than full load conditions without any engine harm..allows me to clear my 17 properties faster...
So my 3 hp 30 year old HSK600 (98cc) at the factory set 4300 rpm (at minimum available torque -according to the performance curve) throws snow way better than my brand new B&S at the factory set 3060 (for max. torque). But I can't use the HSK600 for EOD as it immediately stalls. The B&S I can and do use for EOD because it is set for max. torque, but it won't throw 1" of light fluffy snow out of the chute until about 10' of ground travel and enough snow accumulates inside the auger housing.
I know most of you know the above, but for those that don't...